Diana Investigator Says 'People Will Always Wonder' About Her Death

🎙️ Voice is AI-generated. Inconsistencies may occur.

A police inspector who participated in the British inquiry into events surrounding the death of Princess Diana has expressed her belief that despite doing as thorough a job as possible, "people will always wonder" about Diana's death "because she was so large and no one likes the fact that she's not here anymore."

Jane Scotchbrook, a retired detective superintendent with London's Metropolitan Police who spent over two decades in the criminal investigation division, discussed her role in the Diana inquiry with Christine Lampard on British morning show Lorraine.

Princess Diana 25th Anniversary
Princess Diana photographed in Chicago, June 6, 1996. (Top inset) The princess' return to Britain after her death and (Bottom inset) the car in which she was traveling on the evening she died, August 31,... Tim Graham Photo Library via Getty Images/PIERRE BOUSSEL/AFP via Getty Images

"My main role," Scotchbrook said of the inquiry, which was named "Operation Paget" and looked at a number of conspiracy theories about the princess' death, "was to speak to Diana, Princess of Wales' confidants to try and find out one way or another—it is about following the evidence—whether she was pregnant, whether she was due to get married and whether she had any concerns for her safety."

As part of the investigation Scotchbrook spoke to a number of close friends Diana had spoken to on the telephone in the last days of her life, including wife of the Brazilian Ambassador to Washington Lúcia Flecha de Lima and Daily Mail journalist Richard Kay.

None of those interviewed believed that Diana was either planning on becoming engaged to then-boyfriend Dodi Fayed or starting a family with him. Both of these claims have been publicly repeated by Fayed's father, billionaire Harrods owner Mohamed Al-Fayed.

For more royal news and commentary, check out Newsweek's The Royal Report podcast:

"We looked at absolutely everything," Scotchbrook told Lampard, adding that she was "completely, completely satisfied that we came out with the right result."

The results of Operation Paget were used in a formal inquest into the death of Diana held from 2007 to 2008.

The final ruling from this inquest found that the princess had been unlawfully killed as a result of the "grossly negligent driving" of paparazzi members who followed, at speed, Diana's car as she was being driven from the Ritz hotel in Paris with Dodi Fayed and bodyguard Trevor Rees-Jones, by acting head of security at the Ritz, Henri Paul.

The judge also attributed partial responsibility for the accident to Paul, who was found to have exceeded the legal limit of alcohol consumption to drive.

Princess Diana Journey in Paris
Princess Diana and Dodi Fayed, in the back seat, and bodyguard Trevor Rees-Jones and driver Henri Paul leave the Ritz hotel in Paris before their car crashed in the Pont de l'Alma tunnel on August... Jacques Langevin/scottbaker-inquests.gov.uk via Getty Images

The Mercedes car in which the group was traveling in excess of the speed limit lost control upon entering the Pont de l'Alma tunnel before colliding with a central reservation pillar. Fayed and Paul were pronounced dead at the scene of the accident. Diana was taken to the Pitié-Salpêtrière Hospital, where attempts to save her life were unsuccessful.

Bodyguard Rees-Jones was the sole survivor of the crash. None of the casualties were wearing seatbelts.

Despite the investigation's findings, some still question the official outcome with conspiracy theories continuing to circulate, many of which were addressed in the recent Channel 4 docuseries Investigating Diana: Death in Paris.

Speaking on this subject, Scotchbrook said: "That is the thing with conspiracies, no one wants to believe maybe that this huge personality died as any one of us may do in a car crash."

"There were so many elements to it," she continued, "to get that staged, for so many people to be involved, if there had been a conspiracy for everyone to keep quiet about it—we've just done the best job possible just to prove [what really happened]."

"I think people will always wonder," Scotchbrook ended, "because she was so large and no one likes the fact that she's not here anymore."

Prince William and Prince Harry Diana Statue
Prince William and Prince Harry photographed unveiling a statue to their mother in Kensington Palace's gardens, July 1, 2021. Though there are no official royal plans to mark the 25th anniversary of the princess' death,... Dominic Lipinski - WPA Pool/Getty Images

This year marks the 25th anniversary of Princess Diana's death and to commemorate this a number of TV series, documentaries and biographies have been published celebrating the royal's short life.

Though there are no official royal plans to mark the anniversary, both Princes William and Harry have paid separate tributes to their mother throughout the year, most recently with Harry referencing Diana's relationship with Nelson Mandela in his keynote address at the United Nations in July.

About the writer

James Crawford-Smith is a Newsweek Royal Reporter, based in London, U.K. His focus is reporting on the British royal family and royal fashion. He has covered contemporary and historic issues facing King Charles III, Queen Camilla, Prince William, Kate Middleton, Prince Harry, Meghan Markle, the late Queen Elizabeth II and Princess Diana. James joined Newsweek in 2022 having previously contributed to titles such as The Lady, Majesty Magazine and Drapers. He also spent a number of years working with the curatorial department at Historic Royal Palaces, based at Kensington Palace, and contributed to the exhibitions Fashion Rules: Restyled (2016) and Diana: Her Fashion Story (2017). He also undertook private research projects with the Royal Ceremonial Dress Collection. He is a graduate of University College London and Central Saint Martins, where he studied fashion history. Languages: English.

You can get in touch with James by emailing j.crawfordsmith@newsweek.com.


James Crawford-Smith is a Newsweek Royal Reporter, based in London, U.K. His focus is reporting on the British royal family ... Read more