Amber Heard Trial Could Deter Abuse Survivors Because of 'What She Endured'

🎙️ Voice is AI-generated. Inconsistencies may occur.

Amber Heard's experience in court after being sued for defamation by ex-husband Johnny Depp may deter victims of abuse from speaking out, according to a legal expert.

Heard, 36, announced Monday that she would settle the case after a Virginia court ruled in favor of Depp, 59 who had sued her for $50 million over a 2018 op-ed for The Washington Post.

She wrote in the op-ed that she was a domestic abuse survivor, but did not name her abuser. Heard countersued for $100 million, but Depp's lawyers argued that it was obvious she was referring to the actor.

On Monday, the actress issued a statement on Instagram saying she "simply cannot re-live" another trial if she went on with her appeal.

johnny depp and amber heard
Above, Johnny Depp (L) and Amber Heard (R) attend their trial at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Fairfax, Virginia, on May 24, 2022. Heard said she has decided to settle the defamation case her... Jim Watson/AFP

"Amber Heard was very clear in her statement about why she settled. Heard did not want to prolong a process that had already proved very painful," Carl Tobias, Chair in Law at the University of Richmond told Newsweek.

The law professor said the court verdict could send a negative message to family violence survivors about seeking legal action for their experiences.

"Heard's experience may lead other survivors of abuse to think very seriously about pursuing similar cases, because of the difficulties that she and others have encountered," Tobias said.

Heard had appealed the court's decision in November with her legal team arguing more than a dozen errors they allegedly committed during the trial and called for the June verdict to be reversed or terminated in favor of a new trial.

The trial was scrutinized around the world, with thousands of social media users dissecting every second of the trial

The seven-member jury found Depp was entitled to $10 million in compensatory damages and punitive damages of $5 million. Virginia state law limits punitive damages to $350,000, which brought the amount awarded to Depp to $10.35 million. The jury also awarded Heard $2 million in damages in her countersuit.

In a statement announcing her decision, Heard wrote: "It's important for me to say that I never chose this. I defended my truth and in doing so my life as I knew it was destroyed. The vilification I have faced on social media is an amplified version of the ways in which women are re-victimized when they come forward. Now I finally have an opportunity to emancipate myself from something I attempted to leave over six years ago and on terms I can agree to."

She continued: "I have made no admission. This is not an act of concession. There are no restrictions or gags with respect to my voice moving forward.

The Rum Diary star wrote that she had "lost faith in the American legal system" and felt "vindicated" when the former couple faced a court in the United Kingdom during the trial where Depp took legal action against The Sun newspaper and journalist Dan Wootton for labeling him a "wife beater."

"When I stood before a judge in the UK, I was vindicated by a robust, impartial and fair system, where I was protected from having to give the worst moments of my testimony in front of the world's media, and where the court found that I was subjected to domestic and sexual violence," Heard wrote.

She finished her statement by thanking people for their support and that "time was precious."

"Any survivor knows that the ability to tell their story often feels like the only relief, and I cannot find enough words to tell you the hope your belief in me inspires, not just for me, but for all of you," Heard said.

About the writer

Shannon Power is a Greek-Australian reporter, but now calls London home. They have worked as across three continents in print, newspapers and broadcast, specializing in entertainment, politics, LGBTQ+ and health reporting. Shannon has covered high profile celebrity trials along with industry analysis of all the big trends in media, pop culture and the entertainment business generally. Shannon stories have featured on the cover of the Newsweek magazine and has been published in publications such as, The Guardian, Monocle, The Independent, SBS, ABC, Metro and The Sun. You can get in touch with Shannon by email at s.power@newsweek.com and on X @shannonjpower. Languages: English, Greek, Spanish.



Shannon Power is a Greek-Australian reporter, but now calls London home. They have worked as across three continents in print, ... Read more